ESA Science & Technology - Are mystery Mars plumes caused by space weather?

High-altitude plume on Mars. Credit: W. Jaeschke & D. Parker

Amateur astronomers using telescopes on Earth were the first to report an unusual cloud-like plume in 2012 that topped-out high above the surface of Mars at an altitude around 250 km. The feature developed in less than 10 hours, covered an area of up to 1000 x 500 km, and remained visible for around 10 days.

The extreme altitude poses something of a problem in explaining the features: it is far higher than where typical clouds of frozen carbon dioxide and water are thought to be able to form in the atmosphere.

Indeed, the high altitude corresponds to the ionosphere, where the atmosphere directly interacts with the incoming solar wind of electrically charged atomic particles.

Speculation as to their cause has included exceptional atmospheric circumstances, auroral emissions, associations with local crustal anomalies, or a meteor impact, but so far it has not been possible to identify the root cause.

Unfortunately, the spacecraft orbiting Mars were not in the right position to see the 2012 plume visually, but scientists have now looked into plasma and solar wind measurements collected by Mars Express at the time.

They have found evidence for a large 'coronal mass ejection', or CME, from the Sun striking the martian atmosphere in the right place and at around the right time.

Ground-based and spacecraft measurements of phenomena at Mars during March and April 2012. Click on the image for further details.

"Our plasma observations tell us that there was a space weather event large enough to impact Mars and increase the escape of plasma from the planet’s atmosphere," says David Andrews of the Swedish Institute of Space Physics, and lead author of the paper reporting the Mars Express results.

"But we were not able to see any signatures in the ionosphere that we can categorically say were due to the presence of this plume.

"One problem is that the plume was seen at the day–night boundary, over a region of known strong crustal magnetic fields where we know the ionosphere is generally very disturbed, so searching for 'extra' signatures is rather challenging."

To go further, the scientists have looked at the chances of these two relatively rare events – a large and fast CME colliding with Mars, and the mysterious plume – occurring at the same time.

They have been searching back through the archives for similar events, but they are rare.

For example, the Hubble Space Telescope observed a similar high plume in May 1997, and a CME was registered hitting Earth at the same time.

Although that CME was widely studied, there is no information from Mars orbiters to judge the scale of its impact at the Red Planet.

Similarly, CMEs have been detected at Mars without any associated plume being reported, although changes in distance and visibility of Mars from Earth makes it difficult to acquire good ground-based images at all times.

"The jury is still out as to what physics is at play here, but given the altitude of the plume, we think that plasma interactions must be important," says David.

"One idea is that a fast-travelling CME causes a significant perturbation in the ionosphere resulting in dust and ice grains residing at high altitudes in the upper atmosphere being pushed around by the ionospheric plasma and magnetic fields, and then lofted to even higher altitudes by electrical charging.

"This could lead to a plume effect that is significant enough to be detected from Earth by astronomers."

"A number of processes could be responsible, but if these plumes are indeed driven by space-weather disturbances, this adds an important angle to our understanding of how Mars may have lost much of its atmosphere in the past, changing from a warm, wet world and becoming the cold, dry, dusty place it is today," says Dmitri Titov, Mars Express project scientist.

“The plume also emphasises the scientific potential for continuous monitoring of Mars by both orbiters and ground-based observatories. In particular, we are now going to use the webcam on Mars Express for more frequent coverage of the planet.”

Notes for Editors

Plasma observations during the Mars atmospheric 'plume' event of March–April 2012, by D. Andrews et al., has been accepted for publication in the Journal of Geophysical Research. DOI: 10.1002/2015JA022023.

The measurements were conducted by the Mars Express Analyzer for 
Space Plasmas and Energetic Atoms (ASPERA-3) plasma instrument suite and the Mars Advanced Radar for Sub-Surface and Ionospheric Sounding (MARSIS).

For further information, please contact:

David Andrews
Swedish Institute of Space Physics
Phone: +46 (0) 184715922
Email: david.andrewsirfu.se

Dmitri Titov
ESA Mars Express project scientist
Email: Dmitri.titovesa.int

Markus Bauer






ESA Science and Robotic Exploration Communication Officer







Phone: +31 71 565 6799







Mobile: +31 61 594 3 954







Email: markus.baueresa.int